You Might Also Like
Silly Scents Putty Mystery Egg is rated out of 5 by 10.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Divine from Interesting I bought 4 of these so we could actually experience the surprise. Some of the smells are too much, just too strong. The mud one I had to throw away because I honestly cannot handle the smell. My 4 year old loves the stinky cheese one but I find it almost as bad as the mud. The pickle!! Amazing!!! The smell is spot on! We also got fruit punch which is also great!! I like the idea of the smells and I know the kids think they are fun but they are just a bit to strong in the bad ones. Overall it was pretty fun and the kids are still playing with them. Also it would be much better if the colours were on the packaging so you know which one you're getting.
Date published: 2018-12-23
Rated 1 out of 5 by What's Burning from Is this really what your customers want? I bought one of these tonight for my 4 year old, who was excited to play with silly putty regardless of the smell. Cut to 5 minutes later our house and son smell like a dirty campfire, my wife had to leave the room with a headache and my son is upset that we had to throw it out. This concept is like hey, you'll get a great product sometimes, but sometimes you will get a horrible nasty surprise, yay!
Date published: 2018-11-14
Rated 2 out of 5 by Catmeow from Nice scent, but it lingers Just bought one after seeing it in a local drug store. I really loved the scent of the one I got (I think it was the fruit punch one), but I can't seem to get the smell off my hands. Washed my hands about four or five times so far, but they STILL smell like the putty. I tried to pick something out of my teeth and just tasted a really bad chemical taste. Lemon juice doesn't help get rid of it. Love the scent, but why is it so strong???
Date published: 2018-12-26
Rated 1 out of 5 by Aly2012 from Stinky scents The stinky scents are much too strong for adults, let alone young kids. The yellow silly putty smells like urine. How are kids supposed to play with this? Not sure
Date published: 2019-01-26
Rated 1 out of 5 by Cgillard33 from Be careful.. My boys got these as stocking stuffers. My 2yr old got a tiny piece while my older 2 were playing with it and of course it went in his mouth.. He immediately starting throwing up.. I know it's safe and nontoxic.. It was probably the overpowering scent, but still scary.. Just be careful and make sure the kids don't put it near their mouths!
Date published: 2018-12-26
Rated 1 out of 5 by Kpatt from Rancid waste of money I LOVE Silly Putty and Aarons Putty but let me tell you I'm considering crossing Crayola off the list. I bought one of the scented ones and it happens to be rotten egg scent. It's the most horrid smell out there. It's so bad that it's not even usable which means it was a total waste of money and will end up in the trash. The scented feature was an enticing new element to an otherwise boring and played out world of putty but Crayola screwed up on this one. It's like they thought this would be equally as popular as Jelly Belly's Beanboozled. Wrong! Do not waste a penny on the scented ones because theres a chance you will get one so rancid it can't even be touched. Unless you want to walk around smelling like written egg (which also smells a lot like rancid urine). And if you do, God bless you. But please stay a mile away from me.
Date published: 2019-08-03
Rated 1 out of 5 by kathy from Waste of Money I purchased two of these for grandson. One is dark green and has absolutely no scent. Code on egg says G8L27 and under it is 13:05 H. The other is lighter green and has a scent but is not recognizable to anything on back of card. Code is G8L25 and under it is 19(or 10):44L Seems to be a waste of money, even at $1.99. I give it one star only because it is exciting to open but big disappointment.
Date published: 2018-10-26
Rated 5 out of 5 by AME1990 from Weird and excellent product. We bought one today; it was the stinky campfire-scented one. Though the odor is strong(and not pleasant), I think that this idea is brilliant! I want to get all of the others-and I am 50.
Date published: 2018-12-30
- bvseo_sdk, dw_cartridge, 17.1.0, p_sdk_3.2.0
- CLOUD, getContent, 30ms
- reviews, product